November 1968 Proceedings Magazine: United States Naval Institute


UNITED STATES NAVAL INSTITUTE

For the advancement of professional, literary, and scientific knowledge in the Navy

Board of Control

PRESIDENT

Admiral Thomas II. Moorer, U. S. Navy

VICE•PRESIDENT

Rear Admiral James Calvert, U. S. Navy

SECRETARY•TREASUREM

Commander R. T. L. Howler, Jr., U. S. Navy (Retired)

DIRECTORS
Rear Admiral Henry I.. Miller, U. S. Navy Rear Admiral W. P. Mack, U. S. Navy Brigadier General Herman Poggemeyer,
U. S. Marine Corps
Captain Lawrence Heyworth, Jr., U. 8. Navy Captain Albert A. Heckman, U. S. Coast Guard Captain Raymond A. Komorowski, U. S. Navy

Past Presidents
Admiral David D. Porter 1573
Rear Admiral John L. Wonders 1074
Rear Admiral C. V. R. Rodgers 11174 75, 1552 53 Commodore Foxhall A. Parker 11176-79
Rear Admiral John Rodgers 1117942

Rear Admiral Thornton A. Jenkins l$$1 HI Rear Admiral Edward Simpson MS 57 Rear Admiral Stephen B. Luce 1557 95 Rear Admiral Wm. T. Sampson 1898-1902 Rear Admiral H. C. Taylor 1902-1904
Rear Admiral C. F. Goodrich 1904-1909

Rear Admiral Richard Wainwright 1909 II Rear Admiral Bradley A. Flake 1911-25 Vice Admiral William I.. Rodgers 1923-24 Admiral Henry B. Wilson 1924-26
Admiral Hilary P. Jones 1926-28

Rear Admiral Edward W. Eberle 1928-29 Admiral S. S. Robison 1929-31

Rear Admiral M. L. Bristol 1931-33 Admiral William H. Standley 1933-35 Admiral David Foote Sellers 1935-37 Fleet Admiral William D. Leahy 1937-40 Admiral H. R. Stark 1940-42
Fleet Admiral Chester W. Nimltz 1942-43, 1946-48 Fleet Admiral E. J. King 1943-46
Admiral Louis E. Denfield 1948-50

Admiral Robert B. Carney 1950-52, 1954-56 Admiral William M. Fechtler 1952-54

Admiral Arleigh A. Burke 1956-59, 1960-61 Admiral Jerauld Wright 1959-60

Admiral George W. Anderson, Jr. 1961-63 Admiral David L. McDonald 1963-67

U. S. Naval Institute Staff

Executive Editor
Cdr. R. T. E. Bowler, Jr., U. S. Navy (Retired)

Editorial Director Roger C. Taylor

Jan Snouck-Hurgronje, Assistant to the Editorial Director

U. S. NAVAL INSTITUTE PROCEEDINGS

Editor
Cdr. Robert P. Brewer, U. S. Navy (Retired)

Clayton R. Barrow, Jr., Articles Editor Joel E. Truitt, Departments Editor
Ed Holm, Pictorial Editor
Katherine McInnis, Production Editor
Associate Editors
Capt. W. S. DeLany, Jr., U. S. Navy

Robert A. Lambert Prof. C. P. Lemieux

V. 0. NAVAL INSTITUTE BOOKS
Managing F.ditor
Glen B. Ruh
Lt, Cdr. Arnold S. Lott, U. S. Navy (Retired), Senior Editor

Louise Gerretson, Assistant Editor Mary Veronica Amoss, Assistant Editor Kenneth G. Walsh, Assistant Editor

NAVAL REVIEW

Editor
Frank Uhlig, Jr.
Christine R. Ulrich, Editorial Assistant

ART DEPARTMENT

Director
David Q. Scott

Delroy W. Kiser, Sr., Proceedings Design Gerard A. Valerio, Book Design
Nick Kirilloff, Assistant Book Design
Melbourne Smith, Special Projects Design

MARKETING DEPARTMENT

Director
Richard N. Platt
Fred Stoney, Promotion Manager
Rosemary Cooler, Marketing Assistant

BUSINESS DEPARTMENT

Manager
H. Gordon Williams

Donovan/Burke, Inc. Advertising Department Production Manager: M. A. Thompson
225 Park Avenue, New York, N. Y. 10017 West Coast Representative

9220 Sunset Blvd., Los Angeles, Calif. 90069

Proceedings

November 1968

THE COVER

The color sketch, of a

Navy crewman of a Mobile Support Team (SEAL) PBR on the Bassac River in the Mekong Delta, is one of a series completed by the artist, Mr. Barbary H. Brown, for the U. S. Navy Combat Art Collection under the auspices of the Navy Art Co-operation and Liaison Committee (NACAL).

VOLUME 94, NUMBER 11, WHOLE NO. 789

The U. S. Naval Institute is a private, professional society for all who are interested in naval and maritime affairs. It is a self-supporting, non-profit organization and is not a part of the U. S. Navy Department.

The opinions or assertions in the articles are the personal ones of the authors and are not to be construed as official. They do not necessarily reflect the views of either the Navy Department or the U. S. Naval Institute.

All photographs, unless credited, are official Department of Defense releases.

Editorial and Business Offices: Annapolis, Maryland 21402. Telephone: .301-263-4952.

Published monthly by the U. S . Naval Institute. Second-class paid at the Post Office in MENASHA, WISCONSIN, and at additional mailing office, under act of August 24, 1912. Acceptance for mailing at the special rate of postage provided for in section 1103, Act of October 3, 1917, authorized March 13, 1922.

Membership dues for the U. S. Naval Institute (including PROCEEDINGS), $6.50 a year for the United States and possessions, including FPO and APO addresses. $7.50 for foreign addresses.

Subscription rate $8.50 a year for the United States and possessions, including FPO and APO addresses. $9.50 for foreign addresses. Single copies from current year $1.00. Single copies from previous years $1.00.

Copyright ©1968 by U. S. Naval Institute.

Secretary's Notes 24

Contingency Planning: A New Perspective 26

by Lt. Col. David R. Hughes, USA

The Corsair II As I See It 38

by Cdr. James C. Hill, USN

Needed: Shallow Thinking

by Charles C. Bates, George Tselepis, and Daniel Von Nieda

. . . Justice for All"? 52

by Capt. William G. Proctor, Jr., USMCR

Is SEATO Obsolete? .... . • • 56

by Cdr. Roger J. Miller, USN

The Latin American Military

by Capt. Raymond J. Toner, USN (Ret.)

Gunboats in the Desert 74

by Lt. Charles L. Parnell, USN

Pictorial—Farewell to Chichi Jima

Photography by James F. Falk, JOC, USN

Comment and Discussion 105

Book Reviews 118

Professional Reading 127

Professional Notes 132

The Old Navy 149

Progress 152

Notebook 154

Book List 162

43

64

91