October 1966 Proceedings Magazine: United States Naval Institute
UNITED STATES NAVAL INSTITUTE Proceedings
For the advancement of professional, literary, and scientific knowledge in the Navy
Board of Control
Admiral David L. McDonald, U. S. Navy
Rear Admiral Draper L. Kauffman, U. S. Navy
Commander R. T. E. Bowler, Jr., U. S. Navy (Retired)
Lieutenant General Henry W. Buse, Jr., U. S. Marine Corps
Rear Admiral Henry L. Miller, U. S. Navy Captain Edward L. Beach, U. S. Navy Captain Sheldon H. Kinney, U. S. Navy Captain Malcolm W. Cagle, U. S. Navy
Captain Joseph J. McClelland, U. S. Coast Guard
Admiral David D. Porter 1873
Rear Admiral John L. Worden 1874
Rear Admiral C. R. P. Rodgers 1875-78,1882-83 Commodore Foxhall A. Parker 1878-79
Rear Admiral John Rodgers 1879-82
Rear Admiral Thorton A. Jenkins 1883-85 Rear Admiral Edward Simpson 1885-87 Rear Admiral Stephen B. Luce 1887-98
Rear Admiral Wm. T. Sampson 1898-1902 Rear Admiral H. C. Taylor 1902-1904 Rear Admiral C. F. Goodrich 1904-1909
Rear Admiral Richard Wainwright 1909-11 Rear Admiral Bradley A. Fiske 1911-23 Vice Admiral William L. Rodgers 1923-24 Admiral Henry B. Wilson 1924-26
Admiral Hilary P. Jones 1926-28
Rear Admiral Edward W. Eberle 1928-29 Admiral S. S. Robison 1929-31
Rear Admiral M. L. Bristol 1931-33
Admiral William H. Standley 1933-35 Admiral David Foote Sellers 1935-37 Fleet Admiral William D. Leahy 1937-40 Admiral H. R. Stark 1940-42
Fleet Admiral Chester W. Nimitz 1942-43,1946-48 Fleet Admiral E. J. King 1943-46
Admiral Louis E. Denfeld 1948-50 •
Admiral Robert B. Carney 1950-52,1954-56 Admiral William M. Fechteler 1952-54
Admiral Arleigh A. Burke 1956-59,1960-61 Admiral Jerauld Wright 1959-60
Admiral George W. Anderson, Jr., 1961-63 U. S. Naval Institute Staff
Cdr. R. T. E. Bowler, Jr., U. S. Navy (Retired)
Editorial Director Roger C. Taylor
U. S. NAVAL INSTITUTE PROCEEDINGS
Cdr. Robert P. Brewer, U. S. Navy (Retired)
Assistant Editors Clayton R. Barrow, Jr. Norman Polmar
Katherine McInnis Ed Holm
Capt. Daniel M. Karcher, U. S. Navy, Prof. C. P. Lemieux, U. S. Naval Academy'
U. S. NAVAL INSTITUTE BOOKS
Lt. Cdr. Arnold S. Lott, U. S. Navy (Retired) Assistant Editors
Frank Uhlig, Jr.
Editorial Assistant Mary Veronica Amoss
David Q. Scott
Promotion Manager Fred Stolley
Business Manager H. Gordon Williams
Advertising Representative Donovan/Burke, Inc.
225 Park Ave., New York, N. Y. 10017 9220 Sunset Blvd., Los Angeles, Calif. 90069
October, 1966 The painting of the 165-ton brig Rambler, a typical privateer of the Quasi War with France,
VOLUME 92, NUMBER 10, WHOLE NO. 764 is the property of the Mariners Museum, Newport News, Virginia.
The U. S. Naval Institute is a private, professional society for all who are interested in naval and maritime affairs. It is a self-supporting, non-profit organization and is not a part of the U. S. Navy Department.
The opinions or assertions in the articles are the personal ones of the authors and are not to be construed as official. They do not necessarily reflect the views of either the Navy Department or the U. S. Naval Institute.
All photographs, unless credited, are
Official Department of Defense releases.
Editorial and Business Offices: Annapolis, Maryland 21402.
Published monthly by the U. S. Naval Institute. Second-class postage paid at the Post Office in MENASHA, WISCONSIN, and at additional mailing office, under act of August 24, 1912. Acceptance for mailing at the special rate of postage provided for in section 1103, Act of October 3, 1917, authorized March 13, 1922.
Membership dues for the U. S. Naval Institute (including PROCEEDINGS), $6.50 a year for the United Slates and possessions, including FPO and APO addresses. $7.50 for foreign addresses.
Subscription rate $8.50 a year for the United Slates and possessions, including FPO and 4 PO addresses. $9.50 for foreign addresses. Single copies from current year $1.00. Single r °pies from previous years $1.00.
Copyright (:) 1966 by. U. S. Naval Institute.
Secretary's Notes 4
Divided We Fell 36
by Rear Adm. Kemp Tolley, USN (Ret.)
Naval Forces in River War 52
by Col. Victor J. Croizat, USMC (Ret.)
"Vietnams and Munichs" 62
by George E. Lowe
Treat Sailors Like Spare Parts? 72
by Capt. Arnett B. Taylor, USN
Surveying the Eurasian Arctic 79
by Lt. R. D. Wells, USN
The Cruise of the U-53 86
by Wellington Long
A New International Law for the Submarine? . 96
by Cdr. William 0. Miller, USN
Naval Ordnance Laboratory (Pictorial) . 104
Photography by Marion E. Warren
Comment and Discussion 120
Book Reviews 1 134
Professional Reading 141
Professional Notes 148
A Page from the Old Navy 174
Book List 186
Index to Advertisers 192