Fall 1990 Naval History Magazine
Admiral Donitz at Nurnberg; "Lady Lex" lights up Tacoma 1929; Tetsutaro and Japanese strategy in 20th century; The British Raid on Mount Vernon; The Coast Guard and Mr. Khrushchev
U.S. Naval Institute Fall 1990 Vel. 4, Ne.
6 The British Raid on Mount Vernon
By Fritz Hirschfeld
Offering provisions to the British in April 1781 was one display of southern hospitality that General George Washington detested.
10 The 'Howling Wilderness'
By Brian M. Linn
For U.S. forces on the island of Samar in 1900, the barbarity of the enemy was only one of many problems.
16 An Explanation at Nurnberg
By Captain John P. Bracken, USNR (Ret.)
When Admiral Karl Donitz sought to explain his actions, it was through a fellow naval officer.
18 Two Years Before the Mast: A Reflection
By Irving M. Sternberg
After 150 years, Richard Henry Dana's account of shipboard life is "an incomparable classic of the sea."
22 Dana's Book Stirred the Public, Not Lawmakers
23 The Carrier That Lit Up Tacoma
By Steven A. Payne
The "Lady Lex" was an unlikely power source for drought-ridden Tacoma in 1929.
26 The Battleship and Mr. Shearer
By Lawrence A. Moretz
In the early 1920s, a determined private citizen fought to save the battleship Washington (BB-47) from destruction.
31 Desperate Battle at Unalga Pass
By Robert J. Cressman
When Ensign Albert E. Mitchell's PBY encountered Zero fighters over the Aleutians in early June 1942, the results were tragic, but a boon for the U.S. Navy.
34 Sato Tetsutaro and Japanese Strategy
By Mark R. Peattie and David C. Evans
Japan's naval strategy in the early 20th century was contradictory, but it had great impact.
49 The Coast Guard and Mr. Khrushchev
By Captain B. P. Clark, USCG (Ret.)
The Gresham (WAVP-387), the Coast Guard's "Best Ship," put on her best face to host the Soviet Chief of State in 1959.
Cover: A PBY-5A Catalina flies over the snow-covered Aleutians around 1942 in this beautiful color photo from the National Archives (80-G-K-15434). To read of the fate of one noteworthy Catalina in the Aleutians, see Robert J. Cressman's "Desperate Battle at Unalga Pass," pages 31-33.
Oral History 40
Technical Report 44
GE: More Than Light Bulbs
Oral History 47
Mines at Haiphong: Delayed Execution
The Old Navy 52
When Russian Guns Were Welcome
In Profile 55
Book Reviews 59
Bibliographic Review 63
In Progress 65
In Contact 2, 70
Museum Report 75
The San Diego Maritime Museum
The Old Navy 77
Great Balls of Fire Notebook 79
The U. S. Naval Institute is a private, self-supporting, nonprofit professional society, which publishes Proceedings magazine as a forum for the sea services, and professional books. The Institute is not part of the U. S. Government. Naval History is published quarterly by the U. S. Naval Institute, 2062 Generals Highway, Annapolis, MD 21401. The opinions and assertions herein are the personal ones of the authors. Second class postage paid at Annapolis, MD, and at additional mailing offices. Annual subscription rates: USNI member, $12.00; USNI non-member, $24.00. International subscribers add $4.00. Copyright © 1990 U. S. Naval Institute. Copyright is not claimed for editorial material in the public domain. POSTMASTER: Send address changes to Naval History, USNI, Circulation Department, 2062 Generals Highway, Annapolis, MD 21401. (ISSN 1042-1920)
U.S. Naval Institute Vol. 4, No. 4
Howling Wilderness on Samar
Richard Henry Dana
Khrushchev and the Coast Guard
•., 4 '
,..., .... f - . ........
Behind all the personnel, ships, and weapons that comprise a navy is the strategy that defines its objectives. One of the benefits of history is that it affords us the lens of hindsight. Through that lens we are
able to look back beyond specific battles or campaigns to discern the strategy that shaped them and the naval forces of a given era. Examining World War II has been a popular pastime for many years, reinforced once again now as we move through the period 50 years afterward.
Two of the authors in this issue have provided us with a splendid article on the strategic aims that provided the genesis of the Japanese fleet that fought World War II. David Evans and Mark Peattie have done a first-rate piece of scholarship in examining the sometimes arcane writings of Sat() Tetsutarel and then analyzing those writings and their impact on naval forces. In the early years of the century, Japan sought to move beyond its status as a regional power to achieve much broader influence. Ultimately, the achievement of that goal through military means died with the Japanese surrender in 1945. Two generations later, Japan has achieved its objective of broad influence by economic means—certainly grist for the mill of historians decades in the future.
One way in which the United States sought to thwart Japan's strategic aims in the 1920s was through an international disarmament treaty. An American citizen named William Shearer, however, was not so sanguine about the usefulness of such negotiations and took upon himself a quixotic fight to save the new battleship Washington from destruction, as described in this issue by Howard Moretz.
Two items in this issue deal with Russian visits to America, one by a Russian fleet during the Civil War and another in 1959 by Soviet Premier Nikita Khrushchev. The former visit helped both nations. The latter demonstrated a human side of Khrushchev, although that was scant comfort to the United States at a time when the Cold War was in progress and due to become even chillier a few years later during the Cuban Missile Crisis.
Closely allied with the strategy mentioned above is the business of planning. Many plans never come to fruition, because circumstances aren't right. In one of the oral history memoirs in the issue, the late Rear Admiral Muddy Waters describes the planning to mine Haiphong, North Vietnam, in 1964. Circumstances weren't right then, but they were eight years later, and then the mines were used. Given the impact the mines had when they finally were used, it is interesting to ponder what might have happened if they had been used eight years earlier.
Finally, I would be remiss if I didn't call special attention to this issue's profile. Quiet, unassuming Robert Sherrod has been one of the nation's preeminent journalists for many years. His combat dispatches alone warrant special accolades, but he has done much more. Roger Pineau's description provides the measure of this remarkable man.
BOARD OF CONTROL
President: Admiral Frank B. Kelso II, USN
Vice President: Rear Admiral Vlrgtl L Hill. Jr USN
Executive Director: Captain James A Berber. Jr . USN PE. Directors: Vice Admiral H. B. Thorsen. USCG, Rear Adolf/ J. D. Taylor, USN; Rear Admiral K. Myatt, USNR. Mep Generel M P. Caulfield, USMC; Captain E. G. Wylie, USN; Captein M A McDovel. USN; Ceptain R. T. E. Bowler, USN; Lieutenant T. J. Galpin. USN
Executive Staff: Executive Assistant, Janice E Bat*. AdiNnistrative Assistant, Margie A. Cordle.
Chairman: Vice Admiral H. B. Thorsen, USCG.
Members: Rear Admiral J. D. Taylor, USN; Rear Admirel K Myatt, USNR; Major General M. P. Caulfield, USMC; Captain E. G Wylie. USN. Captain M A McDevitt, USN; Captain R. T. E. gbwler, USN; Lieutenant T. J. Galpin, USN.
Publisher: Captain James A. Barber, Jr., USN (Ret.).
Periodicals and Seminars: Director, Fred H. Rainbow
Naval History/Proceedings/Naval Review: Editor-in-Chief, Naval History, & Senior Editor, Naval Review, Paul Stillwell; Editor-in-Chief, Proceedings/Naval Review, & Executive Editor, Naval History, Fred H. Rainbow; Managing Editor, John G. Miller; Art Director, LeAnn Bauer; Production Manager, Dolores G. Matney; Associate Editors, Linda O'Doughda, Melissa M. McNitt, Brendan M. Greeley, Jr., Fred L. Schultz, Follin Armfield & Anne Collier; Assistant Editor, Russell Brown; Contributing Editors, Lieutenant Christopher A. Abel, USCG, A. D. Baker III, Commander Donald J. Curran, USN. & Lieutenant Commander Thomas Cutler, USN; Consulting Editor, Jack Sweetman; Editorial Assistant/Secretary, Joanne Patmore, Administrative Assistant, Jacquelyn L. Day; Secretaries, Eve Secunda & Ann Allen.
Advertising Department: 225 Park Avenue, New York, N.Y. 10169, (212) 697-2844; FAX (212) 682-1421. Orrecror, James E. Burke; Production Manager, Mary. Alice Thompson, Advertising Coordinator, Emma M. Fortes; Eastern Rep., Dean P Kelly, West Coast Rep Dwight E. Jennett, 777 Silver Spur Road, Palos Verdes Peninsula. CA 90274, (213) 377-3810.
Seminars: Manager, Stacy Wyman, Assistant Seminar Coordinator, Barbara Brendle.
Oral History: Director, Paul Stillwell, Special Assistant/Indexer, Linda O'Doughda; Transcriber, Joanne Patrnore
Library & Photographic Services: Director. Petty M Maddocks; Photo Editor, Linda Cullen; Research Specialist. Dorothy E Sappington; Bookstore Manager/Photo Library Clerk, Virginia Schutt/. Photo Archivist, Mary Beth Straight; Library Assistant, Ann Marie Riordan, Photo/ Certificate Service & Shipping Clerk, Shirley Horton
Membership & Communications: Director, Claudia Zacharias; Membership Promotion Manager, Nancy H Kunkel. Coordinator of Active Duty Programs, Andrea Lyn Chapman. Capital Campaign Director, Lee Holthaus; Development Officer. Joseph DiRenzo III. Development Researcher, Susan B. Sweeney; Advertising/Pudic Relations Coordinator, Jennifer Paytas; Administrative Assistant, Cerol Carbauh; Secretary, Donna M. Bell; Clerk Typist, Helen McMickle
Naval Institute Press: Press Director, Thomes F Epley.
Books: Editorial Director, Thomas F. Epley, Maneger el Acquisitions, Paul Wilderson; Acquisitions Editor, Mark Gatlin, M Editor, Mary Lou Kenney; Senior Manuscript Editor, Carol Swartz; Subsidiary Rights Editor, Dagmar Stock; Import Book Coordinator, Petricia A. Seppington; Manuscript Editor, Anthony F. Chiffolo; Production Editor, Deborah C. Farrell; Assistant Acquisitions Editor, Jennifer Lee. Editorial Assistant, Shannon Becker; Design and Production Manager. John Cronin, Senior Book Designer, Pamela Schnitter; Production Coordinator, Charles E. Vance; Reprint Coordinator, Jean C. Tyson. Administrative & Editorial Assistant, Sandra Kaline; Secretary & Administrative Assistant, Linda McDonnell.
Marketing: Director, Jim Sutton; Assistant Marketing Director/Print Program Manager, Tom Harnish; PublicitylCopy Manager, Susan Artigiani; Administrative & Promotion Assistant, Judy Bray, Advertising/ Direct Mail Manager, Maureen Peterson, Exhibits Manager, Peter Gookin; Secretary, Elizabeth Lewis.
Financial Operations: Director, Mary Kay Meilunas
Personnel: Officer, Barbara A. Brown, Mailroom Manager, George W. Belt; Receptionist/Secretary, Holly Wills.
Accounting: Director, Jerry 0. Sears, Assistant Director, Jeanne Horn; Accounts Payable & Inventory Costing & Control. Julie Lamp; Credit & Collection Manager, Joan Wald; Payroll & Fringe Benefits Manager & Cash Sales, Jane Rice; Accounts Receivable, Ruth Easterling; Accounts Receivable/Data Entry Clerk, Lori A McMillian: Accounting Clerks, Tammy Barber & Sharon Eldridge; Receptionist. Tanje Quarto. Support Operations: Director, Gordon W. Keiser, Administrative Assistant, Margaret F. Golob.
Information Services: Director, James W. Patterson, Systems Analyst, Lee Johnson; Programmer, Jim Jews; Training Coordinator, Maureen Pease; Systems Coordinator/PC Technicien, Linda Miller; Computer Operator, Michele Carroll.
Circulation: Director, Charles P. Mitchell; Assistant Director, Jacquelyn Turner; New Member Representative, Shirley Pecsek; Processing & Billing Assistant, Pat Marcheskie; Data Entry Operator/Membership Records, Susan Baldwin; Research Assistant, Jeanine Shea.
Customer Service: Customer Service Manager, Susan Nelson; Assistant Customer Service Manager, Judith Macaulay, Customer Service Representatives, Beverly House, & Carolyn Davies. Special Order Books, Robyn Julian; Data Entry Operators, Gretchen Kohlweiler & Carolyn M. Adams; Office Assistant, Banta Engelmeyer.
Warehouse: Warehouse Manager, Bob Lemire; Assistant Manager, : Josephine Stacy; Head Shipping Clerk, Harry Schrlefer; Shipping Clerk, Reginald Herndon.
Past Presidents: ADM D. D. Porter; RADM J. L. Worden; RADM C. R. P. Rodgers; COMO F. A. Parker; RADM J. Rodgers; RADM T. A. Jenkins; RADM E. Simpson; RADM S. B. Luce: RADM W. T. Sampson; RADM H. C. Taylor; RADM C. F. Goodrich; RADM R. Wainwright; RADM
B. A. Fiske; VADM W. L Rodgers; ADM H. B. Wilson; ADM H. P. Jones; RADM E. W. Eberle; ADM S. S. Robison; RADM M. L. Bristol; ADM W. H. Standley; ADM D. F. Sellers; ADM W. D. Leahy; ADM H. R. Stark; FADM
C. W. Nimitz; FADM E. J. King; ADM L. E. Denfeld: ADM R. B. Carney; ADM W. M. Fechteler; ADM A. A. Burke; ADM J. Wright; ADM G. W. Anderson, Jr.; ADM D. L. McDonald; ADM T. H. Moorer; ADM E. R. Zumwalt, Jr.; ADM J. L. Holloway Ill; ADM T. B. Hayward; ADM J. D. Watkins; ADM C. A. H. Trost.
Editorial & Business Offices: Annapolis, MD 21402. Phone (301) 2686110. FAX: (301) 269-7940. Published quarterly by the U. S. Naval Institute. Second-class postage paid at the Post Office in Annapolis, MD, & at additional mailing offices. (ISSN: 1042-1920) Annual subscription rates to Naval History are as follows: USNI member, $12.00; USNI nonmember, $24.00; International subscribers, add $4.00. Copyright 1990 by USNI.